07-07-2020, 09:21 PM
Dear JamKazam et al,
Still trying to jam with someone.
Short story:
What am i missing? Or what have i done wrong? Or what should i try?
Any clues would be most appreciated. I've attached some screen shots in cast that helps.
Peace,
Dan
Still trying to jam with someone.
Short story:
- I can do a solo session. 7.3ms delay. All good. Using a Focusrite Scarlett 2i2 3rd Gen.
- My friend can do a solo session. 7.4ms delay. All good. We are “Friends”. He is using a USB mic.
- When we try to join a session together, all we see is the other greyed out with “No audio?”.
- And we get the “Network Send Error.” Over and over.
- And we both tried to join an open session and get the same results for the other “Live Tracks” — greyed out. This points to it being our setup.
- And i now after turning back on "Show Network Alerts" on Manage->Network menu, i get the "Check your network! Your network changed packet port numbers. This may block...".
- Both macOS Mojave 10.14.6.
- Both Jamkazam version Build 1.80 - “1.0.3702”
- Both have a Network “Location” that is set to use a static IP, with WiFi removed from the location.
- Both have setup port forwarding of external UDP ports 12000-12010 to same range internal sending to our respective static IPs.
- Both have IPv6 turned off in Jamkazam.
- Both have JK’s Preferences set ON to always use the same set of UDP ports, and the start is set to 12000.
- Both have Audio Booster set as follows: Auto Throttle Bitrate unchecked, Media Stream unchecked, Chat channel unchecked, Maximum Outgoing Music Bitrate set to 128Kbit/s, Audio FrameSize set to 1ms Experimental, Auto Throttle Network Packet Rate unchecked, Max Network Packet Rate 100Pkt/s. This got me down to 7.3ms delay from 10.3ms.
- Then I realized i had macOS Firewall turned on and so went and set Security & Privacy->Firewall is OFF. Still no changes, except when i went to Search for Open Sessions, when i hovered over one of the people in an open session, it showed my delay as 10ms to that one person — rest all say unknown. Still no love trying to join an open session.
- I have a Verizon FiOS business internet 90Mbps/90Mbps. I didn’t have my friend test his network speed. Friend has Comcast 131Mbps down/6.5Mbps up. Should be no issues with those speeds.
- I have Apple Airport Extreme router with a static IP from Verizon as i run some services. If i go to [/url][url=https://whatismyip.com]whatismyip.com i see the same IP as what i have set my router’s to. This is in regard to some post about having a private IP versus a public IP as some crazy internet providers put you behind some NAT. Friend has DHCP IP for his router but same as what shows up at whatismyip.com.
- In tweaking settings over and over, i would quit and restart Jamkazam many times. At one point, Jamkazam app crashed. I have filed a bug report.
- Oh yeah, in one test with my friend, we heard each other for like 1 second... then it stopped. Retried that setting a few times. No luck.
What am i missing? Or what have i done wrong? Or what should i try?
Any clues would be most appreciated. I've attached some screen shots in cast that helps.
Peace,
Dan